The less instructed atheist will ask whether God can make a weight so heavy that He cannot lift it, in the happy belief that, whichever answer we give, we shall admit that there is something God cannot do. But the question is literally meaningless: a weight than an omnipotent Being cannot lift is as complete a contradiction in terms as a four-sided triangle. In either case the words are English, but do not mean anything because they cancel each other out. There is no point in piling together a lot of words, regardless of their meaning, and then asking triumphantly: 'Can God make that?' God can do anything, but a contradiction in terms is not a thing at all. It is nothing. God Himself could not make a four-sided triangle or a weight that Almighty power could not lift. They are inconceivable, they are nothing; and nothing--to give a slightly different emphasis to Scripture--is impossible to God. . Frank Sheed
About This Quote

Atheists are not the only ones who ask “Can God make a weight so heavy that He cannot lift it?” The problem with this argument is that it assumes God has to be omnipotent in order to create the world. Nothing about the definition of omnipotence requires it. It does not say God can do anything, but not everything. Even if it did, the weight question is meaningless.

It cannot be answered because it doesn’t make sense. It is an English sentence, but there is no point in putting together a lot of words that are contradictory, even though they are meaningful.

Source: Theology And Sanity

Some Similar Quotes
  1. And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love. - Anonymous
  2. Sometimes God allows what he hates to accomplish what he loves. - Joni Eareckson Tada
  3. No woman wants to be in submission to a man who isn't in submission to God! - T.d. Jakes
  4. His hands are holding my cheeks, and he pulls back just to look me in the eye and his chest is heaving and he says, "I think, " he says, "my heart is going to explode, " and I wish, more than ever, that I... - Tahereh Mafi
  5. Why is there ever this perverse cruelty in humankind, that makes us hurt most those we love best? - Jacqueline Carey
More Quotes By Frank Sheed
  1. The less instructed atheist will ask whether God can make a weight so heavy that He cannot lift it, in the happy belief that, whichever answer we give, we shall admit that there is something God cannot do. But the question is literally meaningless: a...
  2. It is of the very nature of partial seeing that we cannot see all the reconciliation of the parts we see, because it is only in the whole that they are one, and we do not see the whole. The word we form cannot wholly...
  3. The Lord has made all things for Himself (Prov.xvi.4): apart from Himself there existed nothing to make them for. He made them for His own sake, for His own pleasure. But it was His pleasure to bring into existence things that could take pleasure in...
  4. ...we can never attain a maximum love of God with only a minimum knowledge of God
Related Topics